The Heroine’s Route is Wrong

Ma Shulan cried and said, "The presiding judge, you heard that she changed the juice and killed my husband. Why is she doing well and I am being prosecuted?"

The presiding judge said solemnly: "Defendant Ma Shulan, please stabilize your emotions, and I will ask your witness's testimony to be consistent with what you know?"

Ma Shulan nodded, and said, "Yes. She secretly changed the juice..."

The presiding judge took a deep breath and said, "Please ask the defender to ask the witness."

The defender said: "Witness, why did you visit Wang Han frequently in October, the month when my client was given the fattening agent, but never again after October?"

Zhao Qingyi said: "The first time I went to have dinner with Wang Han, he touched me shortly after he touched me. I still hope to handle the relationship and protect myself. At that time, I felt that it could be tolerated and it was effective. Wang Han did not go too far. The second time, that is, the first time Ma Shulan was poisoned, Ma Shulan was very enthusiastic to me. Although I found it strange, I still held hope. The third and fourth time I went, Ma Shulan called She gave it to me and invited me. At that time, she was very enthusiastic about me. She was a little bit enthusiastic, so I couldn’t refuse and went. After that, Ma Shulan never invited me, and in November, I got scandalized. I am not in that mood anymore. At that time, I felt that the ecology of Jiangzhou University was not suitable for me. I had already given up psychologically. So I took the Japanese N1 test in December last year and the TOEFL test in mid-January this year. I originally planned to apply this year. A graduate student in a Japanese institution. In short, after November, I was too busy to do so, and Ma Shulan retreated enthusiastically. Both of them didn’t have this heart, so I didn’t go."

The defender said: "It was fine after you changed the juice for the first time. Why did you change the juice for the second and third time?"

Zhao Qingyi said: "A gentleman does not stand under a dangerous wall and faces someone he does not trust. Is there any difference between the second and the third time? Changing the juice is a matter of effort, why not?"

The defender said: "You didn't notice anything unusual about my client at the time?"

"Except for excessive enthusiasm, no more."

"You doubt her, why go there?"

"She warmly invited me. In October, I still want to read a master's degree or even a Ph.D. at Jiangzhou University. Besides, I have to stay on the sidelines so I can meet each other in the future. Defender, don't you understand this?"

There is no problem with the defender. In short, he has no evidence to prove that Zhao Qingyi knew that Ma Shulan had administered the fattening agent.

Then, Mr. Liu from the People’s Hospital was asked to testify. He mainly clarified Wang Han’s physical condition and proved the dosage of the fattening agent he consumed. The dosage of Chen Ming Wang Han’s consumption brought serious harm to his health. Affect his daily life in the future.

After that, there are no new witnesses and exhibits for the defendant, prosecutor, or defender, and the proof-producing process is over.

Then the court debate, the prosecutor first speaks.

The prosecutor said: "Dear presiding judge and people's assessor, I will only express the following opinions on the many issues raised by the defendant that need to be clarified for the reference of the collegial panel:

First, the defendant committed the crime with a strong subjective intention, and until this trial, she still harbored deep hostility towards the witness of this case, Ms. Zhao Qingyi, and still harbored Ms. Zhao Qingyi's affection for Wang Han. Subjective assumptions.

Second, the facts of the defendant’s crime were clear and the consequences were extremely serious. She put the fattening agent in the juice three times, and she knew exactly the consequences of consuming the fattening agent. At this time, the health of the direct victim, Wang Han, was seriously damaged as the best proof.

Third, the defendant never regretted the situation from the beginning to the end. From the first time she committed the crime, she still clearly and subjectively carried out the second and third crimes. The reason was that Ms. Zhao Qingyi did not suffer from infringement, and she felt that she did not achieve her goal. . When she saw that she didn't achieve her goal, the reaction was to continue the violation and never regretted it.

Fourth, the defendant did not voluntarily surrender to the crime. From the last time she administered the medicine, and even more than a month after she knew that her husband Wang Han was directly victimized, she had enough time to surrender to the public security organs, but she did not, instead In Exhibit No. 1, it can be seen that she didn't want to repent and surrender after causing serious consequences, but wanted to ask Ms. Zhao Qingyi why she didn't get fat.

Fifth, during the trial, the defendant still lied in an attempt to shirk responsibility, and the punishment should be increased.

In summary, the facts of the defendant’s crime in this case are clear. Her defense completely ignored the law and relied on subjective assumptions. The accusation that Ms. Zhao Qingyi changed the juice and harmed her is totally untenable in law. I believe that the presiding judge and the people's jurors will be able to distinguish right from wrong, have deep legal wisdom, and will certainly be able to make correct judgments. Thanks! "

After hearing this, Zhao Qingyi raised the corner of her mouth and scratched the back of his hand while holding Yang Peng's finger. When Yang Peng saw her, his eyes were filled with little fairies, and he thought about her plan to study in Japan, but this matter could not be asked now.

The defender faced a pig teammate like Ma Shulan who really wanted to buy a piece of tofu and hit him to death. He had already greeted Wang Jinyu and asked him to persuade Ma Shulan not to be emotional and not to lie in court. She would do the same.

The defender still began to speak: "Dear presiding judge and people's juror: As the defendant of the defendant in this case, I would like to express the following opinions on this case.

In this case, the defender met with the defendant and the direct victim of the case, Wang Han, who is the defendant’s beloved husband. I also fully understood the audio-visual materials and all the evidence of the case, and exchanged the basic situation of the case with the prosecutor. At present, the defender has no objection to the accused by the prosecutor of the crime of intentional assault, but the defender asks the court to adopt it at its discretion:

1. The defendant Ma Shulan in this case did not cause actual physical harm to Ms. Zhao Qingyi, so her criminal purpose was not achieved.

2. It was Mr. Wang Han, who was the husband of the defendant Ma Shulan, who was hurt. Wang Hanhe and the defendant are husband and wife. When Wang Han suffered huge physical injuries, the defendant was still behind bars, causing serious harm to the family. In fact, Wang Han was the last person the defendant wanted to hurt. The defendant can be said to have suffered serious consequences. If the defendant is punished more severely, Wang Han, the direct victim of this case, will suffer more serious injuries.

3. The defendant Ma Shulan in this case was just a woman who loved her husband and lost normal judgment, which caused her to commit a crime. And because her beloved husband accidentally became a direct victim, she felt sad, so she lost control of her emotions and became hostile to Ms. Zhao Qingyi. May I ask which wife can remain calm when her beloved husband is hurt?

In summary, the people’s courts are urged to consider the circumstances when convicting the defendant and sentence them and impose a lighter punishment. "

The presiding judge nodded and said: "According to the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of Flower Planting, the defendant has the right to make the final statement. Defendant Ma Shulan, you can make the final statement."

Ma Shulan was asked to stand up, her feelings of fear, unwillingness, and resentment were entangled in her chest. She said with tears: "I have been given a fattening agent, but I don't want to harm my husband. It is Zhao Qingyi, who changed it. Juice, she harmed my husband, so she should sue the wicked first. You are going to catch her, she should be sentenced to death! The **** should die, why is it so unfair?"

Wang Han, Wang Jinyu, and Dean Li couldn't help but touch their foreheads, and Zhao Qingyi almost laughed.

Shulan kissed and did a great job!

The presiding judge did not comment, and then announced that the evidence was handed over to the court and the trial was over. The collegiate panel deliberated and announced the result after 10 minutes.

Zhao Qingyi waited while playing with Pengpeng's fingers.

Her family Pengpeng is really good-looking, and his hands are so good-looking, Xiao Jianjian approached him again, Yang Peng looked at her tenderly, and he really hugged her and kissed.

Of course no nosebleeds.

After 10 minutes, the presiding judge and people's jurors came back to announce the results. Defendant Ma Shulan was convicted of deliberately injuring and causing serious injuries. There was no remorse or surrender during the whole process. However, considering that she injured her husband, she was slightly punished and sentenced to six years in prison.

The defendant can appeal within the appeal period.

The presiding judge announced that the court was closed, and then the court personnel retired and took the defendant away. Ma Shulan cried and cried, "Jinyu, you can save mom! I was wronged. I don't want to hurt your father. It's that cheap." People have killed our family!"

Wang Jinyu:...

Wang Han knew that even if he wanted Ma Shulan's caregiver, it would not be possible. This is a criminal case, and the state will not reconcile and withdraw the case.

"Go, Jinyu."

The relatives and friends of the Wang family walked to the exit of the court. At this time, the coquettish Xiao Jianjian was taking her family Pengpeng's arm out, and the two stood together like a pair of bi people.

Wang Han, Wang Jinyu, and Dean Li knew her, and their expressions froze.

The coquettish Xiao Jianjian smiled and said, "Professor Wang, the law is the most just. Although Ma Shulan has ruined your health, she has also been severely punished by the law. In the future, you will take care of your illness. You take care and hope that you will be treated again in this life. Don't see you either."

Suddenly, Wang Han's mother spit out and spit at Zhao Qingyi. I saw that coquettish Xiao Jianjian agilely ducked away.

The Queen Mother said angrily: "You are a murderer who has suffered a thousand swords!"

Zhao Qingyi said: "You bastard, you are not dead! Cut!"

With that, she ignored Yang Peng's shock and dragged him away, making the Queen Mother jump with anger.