Legal Affairs: I can see countless loopholes

chapter 2

“How about, with such a huge amount of money for game production and publicity, is there any game studio in China that can do it? And our defendant is actually accusing our game of plagiarizing a small game concept they designed. Is this possible? Is it possible? Say, the hundreds of elite talents in the country’s top game production industry hired by the Penguin Group still need to copy a small studio?”

Lawyer Zhao’s voice fell, but it caused everyone to fall into contemplation.

Yes!

Since the establishment of Penguin Group, the company’s achievements are obvious to all. All the games produced by them have become popular in the market. Moreover, this company has top design talents. In this environment, how can it be plagiarized?

“And, as far as I know, the plaintiff’s company seems to have just transformed into the game design industry, right? In my opinion, the plaintiff should use this lawsuit to attract attention so that they can launch their new game. As for the so-called plagiarism, but It’s just a cover.” After speaking, the lawyer Zhao sneered.

At the same time, when this point of view was raised.

The jury’s face was obviously displeased, and the discussion was already somewhat unfavorable for the plaintiff.

Seeing this, the owner of the small studio sitting on the plaintiff’s seat had an extremely ugly face. He wanted to stand up to refute, but he couldn’t speak, so he had to look at the lawyer’s seat as if asking for help, but when he saw Qin who was indifferent. When Mu, he couldn’t help but despair.

“Your Excellency, to sum up the above, I think it can be judged that the plaintiff’s reporting purpose is not good, and the Penguin Group should be forgiven for its guilt. At the same time, the case should be cancelled.” When he said this, his face showed pride.

After all, from what it looks like now, the case is won.

As for the plaintiff’s lawyer, it has never been taken seriously. Even the industry leaders are not his opponents. What’s more, it’s just a newbie? The judge on the bench also raised the sentencing hammer in his hand, intending to adjourn the court and announce the result. However, at this time, Qin Mu, who had not spoken for a long time, finally spoke up: “Wait, Your Excellency, I have a problem.”

“Speak.” He put down the hammer in his hand and nodded.

“First of all, I would like to ask my client, according to the data, what stage is your studio’s game in development at present?”

“BUG is being tested, and it is expected to be released in half a year.”

“That said, the game hasn’t started testing yet, right?”

“Yes.”

“So, in other words, your company doesn’t have a formal promotion plan, does it?”

“Yes!”

The plaintiff answered one by one, at this time, the sitting lawyer Zhao changed a little, suddenly realized a problem, and quickly stood up and said: “Your Excellency, I object, the plaintiff’s lawyer is here to ask some questions. Pointless questions and a complete waste of our time.”

“Meaningless question? Is that right? Does lawyer Zhao’s malicious guidance of the jury just now make sense?”

“you……”

Hearing this, Lawyer Zhao’s face was a little ugly. He wanted to stand up and press him, but when he looked at each other, he found that Qin Mu’s eyes were sharper than his words. Is this really a newcomer? If it was already on the lips, I couldn’t help swallowing it.

“The objection is invalid, and Lawyer Qin continues.”

The judge seemed to have heard something, so he opened his mouth.

“Your Majesty, the reason why I asked these questions just now was to correct a point. First of all, my client absolutely did not use the Penguin Group to build momentum, because their company’s game is still in the testing state, and there is still some time before the official launch. Therefore, the so-called bad report put forward by the defendant’s lawyer is obviously a false change of concept.” Qin Mu said lightly.

The words fell, and lawyer Zhao’s brows could not help wrinkling. Staring at Qin Mu cautiously, he actually underestimated this rookie lawyer and broke his game. After all, if the jury were given a mentality that the plaintiffs would take advantage of them, the lawsuit would be a sure thing.

But I didn’t expect it to be broken now.

When the plaintiff heard this, his eyes lit up. As for the surrounding jury, the attitude has begun to ease.

“I object. The plaintiff’s lawyer’s statement lacks evidence. Even if it is temporarily unavailable, it is not impossible to use fishing boats for publicity.”

“Yes, my statement lacks evidence, but does Lawyer Zhao have any evidence that my client’s lawsuit is because he wants to use the Penguin Group for publicity?” Qin Mu smiled faintly, but the latter was speechless for a while.

After all, where does he have evidence?

If there is, then this lawsuit does not need to be fought at all.

“Well, plaintiff’s lawyer, you continue.”

The judge nodded in agreement. Since there is no evidence on both sides, then of course there is no point in continuing on this matter. Now, it is to see who can produce stronger evidence.

“Your Majesty, in my opinion, this case is actually very simple. It only needs to prove one point, that is, when did the game “Cross Frontier” developed by the Penguin Group start, then, it is enough Explain, is there any plagiarism.” Qin Mu’s voice fell.

Lawyer Zhao, who was slumped, stood up again and said: “This is simple, as we all know, this game of Penguin Group was released a month ago, and the online rate once exceeded 10 million level, so at this time, It is already quite obvious who researches first and who researches later.”

“I object!”

Before he could finish speaking, Qin Mu had already spoken.

“If it looks from the release time alone, then it is indeed “Crossing the Frontier” first, but according to the data, since the game was launched, there have been many bugs, and the number of maintenance updates has been Hundreds of times, in just over a month, the average daily maintenance is three times. From here, we should be able to see some problems, that is, the Penguin Group did not pass the bug test when it launched the game. So, The question is, why are they in such a hurry to go online?”

“Your Excellency, I would like to ask the chairman of the Penguin Group to answer this question directly.”

Qin Mu’s faint voice fell, but it made everyone feel doubts.

Attorney Zhao, who was sitting, began to sweat on his forehead. As a professional gold lawyer, he knows that the seriousness of this problem, if he can’t come up with strong evidence to prove that “Cross Frontier” is launched ahead of schedule, then it is likely to become a breakthrough in this lawsuit. .